Is It Worth It to Hire a Property Manager in San Diego? Here’s the Math.

If you're self-managing your Airbnb or VRBO listing in San Diego, you've probably asked yourself:
"Should I hire a property manager, or keep doing it myself?"

The short answer? If you're doing this as a side hustle or investing for passive income, hiring a professional can make a huge difference in both revenue and time saved.

Let’s break down what San Diego property managers actually do, how much they charge, and whether it’s really worth the cut.

🧾 What Does a Vacation Rental Manager in San Diego Do?

A full-service short-term rental property manager typically handles:

  • Listing optimization (Airbnb, VRBO, etc.)

  • Dynamic pricing & calendar management

  • Guest communication (24/7)

  • Professional cleaning & turnover coordination

  • Maintenance dispatching

  • Supply restocking & inventory control

  • Regulatory compliance (TOT registration, license checks)

  • Smart lock & tech support

  • Reviews management and guest conflict resolution

  • Extended stay placements via insurance, relocation, and corporate housing partners (SuperStay)

  • Premium distribution channels like Marriott Homes & Villas (SuperStay)

In other words: they turn your home into a revenue-generating business while you stay hands-off.

💰 What Do Property Managers in San Diego Charge?

In 2025, here’s what you’ll typically see:

SuperStay Rentals, for example, offers full-service turnkey management starting at 20% with zero hidden fees.

🧮 Real Example: DIY vs. Full-Service Management

Let’s say you own a 2-bedroom condo in Pacific Beach. You’re self-managing today and making $83,000/year in gross revenue — not bad.

But here’s what happens when you switch to a top-tier property manager like SuperStay, which uses:

  • Dynamic pricing tools

  • Extended stay placements via insurance, relocation, and corporate housing partners

  • Premium distribution channels like Marriott Homes & Villas

With these tools, top-performing properties often see 10-30% higher revenue. For this example, we’ll use $115,000 gross.

🔍 When Does Hiring a Manager Make Sense?

✅ You live outside of San Diego

✅ You work full-time or have other commitments

✅ You want better guest reviews & more bookings

✅ You’re overwhelmed by the logistics

✅ You want to stay compliant with city laws and avoid fines

If you check even two of those boxes, a property manager can increase your ROI and peace of mind.

🏁 Final Thoughts: Is It Time to Let Go of the Day-to-Day?

Short-term rental income can be passive — but only if you let someone else do the heavy lifting.

At SuperStay Rentals, we help San Diego homeowners earn more, stress less, and run fully compliant, high-performing listings. Whether you’re burnt out from DIY hosting or just exploring your options, we’d be happy to run a free performance forecast for your property.

📞 Curious What You Could Be Earning With Professional Management?
Get a Free Revenue Estimate — personalized, no obligation.

Previous
Previous

How to Maximize Your Airbnb Revenue in San Diego: 7 Local Strategies That Work

Next
Next

How Much Can You Really Make on an Airbnb in San Diego? Market Data Inside.